Comstock Partners, Inc.August 22, 2013
The Market Outlook Has Taken A Turn For The Worse
Last week’s breakdown from a consolidation top looks more and more like a significant change in market trend to the downside on both a fundamental and technical basis.
Technically, the sharp move down was a classic definition of a breakaway gap, typified by a daily high that was lower than the prior day’s low in a direction opposite to the previous market trend. In addition, the August 2nd peak in the S&P 500 was not accompanied by a new high in breadth while the 10-day average of new daily NYSE highs was only 400, compared to 800 during the period of the May highs in the market. It is also significant that the decline occurred from the top of an aging bull market that had gained 156% in four years and five months.
Fundamentally, as well, the market appears to be reacting to some important changes in comparison to the last few years. The Fed, in posing the strong probability of a finite limit on quantitative easing (QE), has changed the nature of the game. The market climbed strongly during QE1 and QE2, only to correct when they ended. To avoid that pitfall, the Fed made QE3 and QE4 open-ended, and the market accordingly responded with a strong bullish move. Now that period is over, and whether tapering occurs in September or December or early next year doesn’t matter as much as the fact that the market focus has been changed toward anticipating a finite ending as illustrated by the sharp rise in the 10-year yield.
This is happening at the same time that corporate earnings growth is slowing down after rising rapidly since the end of the recession. It was this factor combined with the QE programs that kept the market going higher despite an extremely sluggish economic recovery. From 2008 through 2011 S&P 500 earnings increased 95%, but only 2% annualized since then. In addition forward-looking estimates are being revised down, and still appear to be too high. This is confirmed by recent disappointments at key companies such as Wal-Mart, Macy’s, Cisco, IBM, Amazon and Google.
The market is continuing to receive minimal support from the economy, which has been slogging along at about a 2% growth rate for the last three years. Real disposable income has risen by an average of only 0.5% year-to-year over the first six months of 2013, and retail sales have been accordingly tepid with little room left to reduce an already low consumer savings rate. Job growth remains inadequate with an unusual proportion of employment gains coming in low-paying industries and part-time jobs. Now, the sharp increase in mortgage rates threatens the growth of the housing industry as well, with monthly payments on a $300,000 mortgage rising by 14% or close to $200. Add to that mix an escalating crisis in the Mid-East, the likelihood of a 3rd Greek bailout and the coming conflict in Washington over the budget and debt limit.
In sum, it appears to us that the character of the market has taken a significant turn for the worse, and that the period ahead will be far more difficult than the years since 2009. Now selling at 19.5 times trailing reported (Gaap) earnings on the S&P 500, the market is highly overvalued compared to the long-term norm of 15 times and its bear market lows under 10. In our view, the potential downside for the market is unusually high.